EDIT: Here's what I've posted in the dev forums on the matter:
Rhino wrote:With fixing up the Super Etendard cockpit, I've come back to the question of is it worth having 1st person canopy glass in jets? I did a quick bit of research, looking at all our current jets and categorised them into three groups:
Detail Glass:
Jets, where there 1p glass, has some form of texture on it, ideally some kind of detail like explosive cord woven into it like the Harrier.Plain Glass:
- Harrier: https://i.imgur.com/pE5VKyK.jpg / https://i.imgur.com/sZPRmJG.jpg
- Tornado: https://i.imgur.com/TBtQghx.jpg / https://i.imgur.com/xu3CfSQ.jpg
Jets that have 1p glass, but are a plain texture with no detail, not even scratches. No Glass:
Jets that have no 1p glass, excluding the HUD.My results show that 80% of our Jets had no 1p Canopy Glass at all. These are mainly made up of vBF2 models which this seemed to DICE's standard for BF2, and most other jets have taken this standard. Only 10% of our Jets have any detailed texture for their 1p glass, and the Harrier is really the only one that needs this, the Tornado's is so low rez it just looks like **** and would probably be better to have it removed. Even the Harrier's texture right now is a bit counterproductive with its low rez for 1p; I'm guessing it shares the same 3p texture for 1p.
- Mirage 3 / Dagger: https://i.imgur.com/XA1QPRi.jpg
- Su-22: https://i.imgur.com/Hwj4wQE.jpg
- Su-25: https://i.imgur.com/XTHnFSf.jpg
- Su-27: https://i.imgur.com/DcBztKv.jpg
- MIG-21: https://i.imgur.com/hrE2EVB.jpg
- A-10: https://i.imgur.com/p3x7MwF.jpg
- F-16: https://i.imgur.com/YrT0UKZ.jpg
- Q-5 (vBF2): https://i.imgur.com/9JTiDvs.jpg
- J-10 (vBF2): https://i.imgur.com/6XkNbIO.jpg
- Su-30Mkk (vBF2, camera could probaly be moved back a bit too): https://i.imgur.com/M637IqV.jpg
- EF2000 (vBF2): https://i.imgur.com/c1VtFCZ.jpg
- MIG-29 (vBF2): https://i.imgur.com/mxdd0vn.jpg
- Su-34 (vBF2): https://i.imgur.com/xHzs7z4.jpg
- Su-39 (vBF2?): https://i.imgur.com/oX9BRE2.jpg
- F-15E (vBF2): https://i.imgur.com/e33vyCq.jpg / https://i.imgur.com/wZYHXqR.jpg
- F-18 (vBF2): https://i.imgur.com/njvljF8.jpg
I think unless we are going to do really high-resolution textures with lots of scratches and the like on them, or any other key details like the Harrier's 1p texture, it is probably best not to have any Canopy Glass for the 1p Cockpit Model. If you also go with high res glass textures, then is it worth the extra memory of those high res DXT5 textures?
Standardise our jets to have no 1p Canopy Glass, if we choose to, is much easier since most of them are already there and updating vBF2 jets to have glass is waaay too much effort to consider.
So unless the majority disagree, I'm not going to have any 1p glass for the Super Etendard.
Our Choppers are a different story. Without looking at them, I believe a much higher percentage have 1st person glass canopies, except for the vBF2 models which like the jets, don't have any 1p glass. Would need to separate topic to go into this further.