Real D-Day experience

Suggestions from our community members.
Post Reply
xambone
Posts: 548
Joined: 2010-04-20 16:58

Real D-Day experience

Post by xambone »

I have studied this part of history and while I do enjoy Operation Overlord I feel like the map is only half way done. I think that you should allow paratroopers during the first 10-30 mins, and allow the city in the Northwest to become a capture point along with the first flags on the beach. This would simulate how the germans were confused and divided. This would also allow for the use of the AA guns. This would free up landing for the boats as the Germans would be divided.

It basically creates a more realistic situation.
Rabbit
Posts: 7818
Joined: 2006-12-17 15:14

Re: Real D-Day experience

Post by Rabbit »

xambone wrote:I have studied this part of history and while I do enjoy Operation Overlord I feel like the map is only half way done. I think that you should allow paratroopers during the first 10-30 mins, and allow the city in the Northwest to become a capture point along with the first flags on the beach. This would simulate how the germans were confused and divided. This would also allow for the use of the AA guns. This would free up landing for the boats as the Germans would be divided.

It basically creates a more realistic situation.
You have problems with that.

In AAS everything has to be captured in a certain order. So they would have to link up at some point, which would probably be while the Americans are on the beach. So you would have people attacking from in front and behind, which leads to the second problem.

If the paratroopers will link up at the bunkers, why the hell spawn on the beach to get mowed down? Everyone would be spawning as paratroopers as its less suicidal.

With less people assaulting the beach, less targets, easier to repel the beach.

Paratroopers assaulted farther inland, to prevent counter attack and resupply/ reinforcement, they never went after the fortifications overlooking the beach.

We currently have several things yet to be seen that will greatly improve the overall historical accuracy of d-day and help the US get off the beach.
Image

AfSoccer "I just don't see the natural talent."
Image
Adetter
Posts: 604
Joined: 2009-02-26 17:08

Re: Real D-Day experience

Post by Adetter »

There's actually an own map focusing on the paradrop the night before the Normandy landings.
Can't wait to see a map of the battle of Carentan and a better version of the German counter-attack (Bloody Gulch/Hill 30). Plenty of great map ideas to choose from for the map creators such as Chambois, St. L? etc.
Post Reply

Return to “PR:WWII Suggestions”