Forum poll bug?

Post Reply
saamohod
Posts: 300
Joined: 2011-01-12 16:15

Forum poll bug?

Post by saamohod »

It isn't a game bug but since I couldn't find Forum Feedback/Questions Section, I post it here. Did you people notice that poll percentage calculator works in an odd way? Have a look at this thread for example and add all the percentages https://www.realitymod.com/forum/f10-pr ... ost1938415. It will make way more than 100%.
ghostfool84
Posts: 503
Joined: 2009-10-17 11:38

Re: Forum poll bug?

Post by ghostfool84 »

because its a Multiple Choice Poll maybe?
saamohod
Posts: 300
Joined: 2011-01-12 16:15

Re: Forum poll bug?

Post by saamohod »

ghostfool84 wrote:because its a Multiple Choice Poll maybe?
Maybe, but it still seems it makes little sense having over 100% in total. This number would give us no useful information.
nAyo
Posts: 571
Joined: 2008-10-29 22:07

Re: Forum poll bug?

Post by nAyo »

Total is 188,9. Doesn't make sense at all indeed!

This one https://www.realitymod.com/forum/f252-p ... ack-7.html works well so it must have something to do with multiple choices.
Image
"I, for one, am not a dictator. I'm the Supreme Leader" - Master
havoc1482
Posts: 315
Joined: 2009-02-28 19:39

Re: Forum poll bug?

Post by havoc1482 »

ghostfool84 wrote:because its a Multiple Choice Poll maybe?
But that still doesn't make sense. Its a multiple choice poll, yes, but it should break down the percentage out of 100 between all of the choices. Say I choose 3 maps, that should be no different than a single choice poll and having 3 individuals vote once for each map. You get what I'm saying?
Image
Image
ImageImage
ghostfool84
Posts: 503
Joined: 2009-10-17 11:38

Re: Forum poll bug?

Post by ghostfool84 »

Yeah, you are right, i just didnt think much about it, but are other votes except the multiple choice ones also affected?
PR0_SNIPE
Posts: 149
Joined: 2013-06-29 13:08

Re: Forum poll bug?

Post by PR0_SNIPE »

Well it seems like the colors cycle after 6 different choices so maybe the first 6 add up to 100% and then the next 6 reset and add up to 100% too.
You're hit and then hear the shot.
saamohod
Posts: 300
Joined: 2011-01-12 16:15

Re: Forum poll bug?

Post by saamohod »

PR0_SNIPE wrote:Well it seems like the colors cycle after 6 different choices so maybe the first 6 add up to 100% and then the next 6 reset and add up to 100% too.
That was very good observation. The first cycle indeed makes 100%.
nAyo
Posts: 571
Joined: 2008-10-29 22:07

Re: Forum poll bug?

Post by nAyo »

Good observation, but the second cycle only makes 88,9% so it doesn't really make sense?

EDIT : I got how it works. The first cycle (6 first options) are the ones who are added up to make 100%. Then all the other ones are based on this first cycle to estimate their percentage.


  • 57 28.08% Al Basrah
  • 22 10.84% Black Gold (v1.0)
  • 8 3.94% Dragon Fly
  • 80 39.41% Fallujah West
  • 22 10.84% Gaza Beach
  • 14 6.90% Iron Ridge
= 203 votes = 100%
The bottom ones are not considered in it

  • 11 5.42% Karbala
  • 33 16.26% Kokan
  • 30 14.78% Korengal Valley
  • 36 17.73% Lashkar Valley
  • 16 7.88% Operation Archer
  • 55 27.09% Ramiel
Nothing is added up here
Amount of votes are just compared to 203
Like 11 out of 203 = 11*100/203 = 5.42% hence QED

Yes I am a mathematics student so this concerned me a lot :D
Last edited by nAyo on 2013-08-30 00:10, edited 10 times in total.
Image
"I, for one, am not a dictator. I'm the Supreme Leader" - Master
Post Reply

Return to “General Technical Support”