ISIS as a faction?

General discussion of the Project Reality: BF2 modification.
Guynumber7
Posts: 4
Joined: 2013-06-10 01:53

ISIS as a faction?

Post by Guynumber7 »

Would it be possible to add them one day? They would be very similar to the other militia factions but they would have stolen Humvees.

They could also face off vs Syrian Rebels in Insurgents vs Insurgents which would be awesome.
H.Maverick
Posts: 716
Joined: 2010-07-03 12:56

Re: ISIS as a faction?

Post by H.Maverick »

Taliban, give'em Humwees, and some old APC's.

Done.

Also, no, if you want ISIS you will sadly need to make them yourself as in get a mod team together...

Would be cool to be on the bluefor side though, F15's, F16's and what not, just dropping bombs all over the place... sweet :P
Its SO evil, it may actually encourage EA to support Modding again - Pantera

Image

Image
Jacksonez__
Posts: 1090
Joined: 2013-07-28 13:19

Re: ISIS as a faction?

Post by Jacksonez__ »

Go ahead and start mapping a map that would feature ISIS. You really cannot request factions from the devs. You either work on them yourself or find really kind people that do all that for you :-D
sgtsev3n
Posts: 187
Joined: 2014-12-15 23:18

Re: ISIS as a faction?

Post by sgtsev3n »

better not.

some arma 3 modders did the ISIS faction, basically different modders created ISIS faction for theyr own mod/factionpack, there was more than 3 different ISIS faction mod out there. later, the dailymail released a article about the mods and claimed that the modders support ISIS and the mod was made to simulate the killing of civilians as a ISIS fighter and blablabla.

so after that, the modders stopped theyr ISIS mod.
one mod was a factionpack that included ISIS, after the release of dailymail article, the modder changed the faction to a generic iraqi terrorist or insurgent faction, removed all ISIS logos etc from the units.
the other modder removed his mod and disappeared completely.
and another modder removed also his ISIS faction from his pack.

but there are now other modders starting ISIS faction again.

anyway, it could lead to problems as you see.
SShadowFox
Posts: 1118
Joined: 2012-01-25 21:35

Re: ISIS as a faction?

Post by SShadowFox »

PR works with generic insurgent factions, such as the Iraqi Insurgents for insurgents in Iraq. Syrian Rebels represent not only the FSA, but also also every other rebel group actively fighting in Syria. The Taliban is the Afghan insurgent faction. And there's finally the Militia which represents mainly Eastern European rebels.

ISIS is a very specific group, but that could very well fit into one of the existing insurgent factions, there's just no reason to make it more complicated by adding just one more faction that wouldn't add much to the game. Vehicles aren't faction-locked, you can very well (as a mapper) set the Iraqi Insurgents to be able to drive a Humvee for example, there's no need to make an entire "new" faction just for that.
Image
[R-DEV]Spec:The suggestion is not accepted, I merely wanted to comment.

Shame doesn't work on me, Nor on men of my caliber.
LiamNL
Posts: 585
Joined: 2013-06-15 08:13

Re: ISIS as a faction?

Post by LiamNL »

Maybe we could make a Palmyra map with Iraq insurgent faction + a couple of extra vehicles vs either MEC or Syrian rebel faction?
ComradeHX
Posts: 3294
Joined: 2009-06-23 17:58

Re: ISIS as a faction?

Post by ComradeHX »

Step 1: play insurgency map with Iraqi insurgents or FSA.
Step 2: make squad called ISIS.
...
Airsoft
Retired PR Developer
Posts: 4713
Joined: 2007-09-20 00:53

Re: ISIS as a faction?

Post by Airsoft »

ComradeHX wrote:Step 1: play insurgency map with Iraqi insurgents or FSA.
Step 2: make squad called ISIS.
...
Then proceed to create another squad called al-Nusra and proceed to tk each other
Image

Image
KillJoy[Fr]
Posts: 838
Joined: 2010-12-28 20:51

Re: ISIS as a faction?

Post by KillJoy[Fr] »

Don't cross the line, it's nearly apology of terrorism and making a faction will glorify their crimes. We have Talibans, Iraqi insurgents, and Syrian rebels enough is enough.
Au dela du possible ...
IINoddyII
Retired PR Developer
Posts: 2268
Joined: 2008-02-06 03:12

Re: ISIS as a faction?

Post by IINoddyII »

Agree a bad idea... Some publicity is bad...
Switchback
Posts: 9
Joined: 2013-08-16 02:43

Re: ISIS as a faction?

Post by Switchback »

Actually had this discussion with squadmates ingame a few days ago.

Generally speaking, I don't think the PR devs would devote resources to this, especially given the minefield it would bring with the media, and could potentially get EA to start some sort of legal action against PR for BF2 asset use, etc. (Uneven case aside, it would still put a wrench in the works). Hell, this could even blow over into Squad's development (Bad press), which is sort of key right now in their kickstarter phase.

PR seems to be doing fine hiding in the shadows of the big commercial monstrosities (ARMA Franchise), lets leave it there. From what I've seen PR didn't really announce Standalone much (Other than normal trailer), and look how fast the servers went from zero to full.
Guynumber7
Posts: 4
Joined: 2013-06-10 01:53

Re: ISIS as a faction?

Post by Guynumber7 »

I dont believe that there is ANY such thing as bad publicity for a free video game mod.
Cossack
Posts: 1689
Joined: 2009-06-17 09:25

Re: ISIS as a faction?

Post by Cossack »

Guynumber7 wrote:I dont believe that there is ANY such thing as bad publicity for a free video game mod.
Well, this mod does not have that big media coverage. But take a look at Medal of Honor reboot, they had Taliban faction and in the end they had to rename it or else...
Image

ImageImageImage
MUSTARDGAs
Posts: 94
Joined: 2015-02-02 03:04

Re: ISIS as a faction?

Post by MUSTARDGAs »

sgtsev3n wrote:better not.

some arma 3 modders did the ISIS faction, basically different modders created ISIS faction for theyr own mod/factionpack, there was more than 3 different ISIS faction mod out there. later, the dailymail released a article about the mods and claimed that the modders support ISIS and the mod was made to simulate the killing of civilians as a ISIS fighter and blablabla.

so after that, the modders stopped theyr ISIS mod.
one mod was a factionpack that included ISIS, after the release of dailymail article, the modder changed the faction to a generic iraqi terrorist or insurgent faction, removed all ISIS logos etc from the units.
the other modder removed his mod and disappeared completely.
and another modder removed also his ISIS faction from his pack.

but there are now other modders starting ISIS faction again.

anyway, it could lead to problems as you see.
Heres a link to it
ISIS distributing video game that allows players to play role of an Islamist and kill Westerners? | Daily Mail Online


I haven't laughed that much in years man thanks.
There is no "overkill". There is only a disproportionate appliance of force.
Madar_al_Fakar
Posts: 225
Joined: 2015-04-02 20:28

Re: ISIS as a faction?

Post by Madar_al_Fakar »

mehason wrote:Is it possible to give talibans US kits? So they will look like Iraq army.
So the weapons are the only thing that differentiates the Taliban between the Iraqi Army how about the uniforms (Taliban dress like their going to heard sheep, Iraqs soldiers have uniforms, don't wear turbans............)? XD llollol
Also on topic: I don't think we need ISIL, they would add nothing worth mentioning to the game.
"ISIS distributing video game that allows players to play role of an Islamist and kill Westerners? | Daily Mail Online
" AHAAhaahahahahaahahahahahahahah looooooooool yeah, with such imbeciles working for the press, PR better stay under the radar. xD
H.Maverick
Posts: 716
Joined: 2010-07-03 12:56

Re: ISIS as a faction?

Post by H.Maverick »

ComradeHX wrote:Step 1: play insurgency map with Iraqi insurgents or FSA.
Step 2: make squad called ISIS.
...
[R-DEV]Airsoft wrote:Then proceed to create another squad called al-Nusra and proceed to tk each other

This... This could work very well xD

There usually is a "ISIS" squad on every ins map these days anyways
Its SO evil, it may actually encourage EA to support Modding again - Pantera

Image

Image
Jacksonez__
Posts: 1090
Joined: 2013-07-28 13:19

Re: ISIS as a faction?

Post by Jacksonez__ »

H.Maverick wrote:This... This could work very well xD

There usually is a "ISIS" squad on every ins map these days anyways
When al-Nusra squad is near Mosque area, ISIS squad comes in with Gary and teamkills them :-) :smile: Then there would be civil war in insurgency team.
DankLoser
Posts: 18
Joined: 2017-05-03 08:30

Re: ISIS as a faction?

Post by DankLoser »

I think the Iraqi Insurgents as supposed to be ISIS
Post Reply

Return to “PR:BF2 General Discussion”