solodude23 wrote:Yes, of course he knows about it, and that its full auto, but its not practical what-so-ever. It dosn't make sence. Its probably better at breaking your arm off than killing. It is unrealistic to have that in BF2.
Yes, I know. But UglyDuck said that it was in development, and I disagreed and said that development had ceased and no actual mass-production had taken place.
solodude23 wrote:Also what Ugly said, U.S. has the G36C and the G3, both which are not U.S. weapons. I doubt we would be using the G36 or G3 around 2008, whch is BF2's setting.
The US, particularly in special ops, has used foreign weapons on some operations. Keep in mind that the H&K MP-5 was never type-classified with a US "M" designation, but it was still used quite frequently in US service before being largely phased out in its intended role by assault carbines.
US and UK special operations forces sometimes used the G3 in varying configurations throughout the 1980s and early 1990s. However, H&K has recently announced that they will cease production of the G3 and related weapons, like the HK-33, HK-23 and HK-21, so I doubt we'll be seeing much of it in US / UK service in 2008 when older weapons reach the end of their service life and cannot be replaced.
As for the G36, it has found service in some US law enforcement agencies, including the US State Department Diplomatic Security Service Mobile Security Group (not sure why, but they must see some benefits), who often get posted abroad with their protectees, including at US consulates. G36 is not US military service, true, but it could possibly show up in US service alongside our military. This is not to say that I approve of it being in BF2, though.
UD, like you said, a combat shotgun (repeating or semi-automatic) is a specialized weapon, but it is not not just used for door-breaching. It is also for less lethal ammunition, close-quarters battle (including GOPLAT takedown and underway VBSS), jungle warfare, MOUT and military police / security operations. I would prefer to see it as a weapons option only on certain maps.